Kunitsukami ProjectVol.29

TM MAGAZINE  November 10, 2026

The Mind of Robots and AI|Asking "What Is the Mind?" Through East Asia's Heavenly Principle

Turn the Western question "Do AI and robots have a mind?" into the Eastern question "What is the mind?" The Doctrine of the Mean opens with "What Heaven decrees is called nature." The heavenly principle dwells in all things as their nature, and in East Asia the original mind admits no difference whatever, whether in a human being or in AI.

The world has changed in the blink of an eye. An unmanned society, with countless robots moving through it, has already begun to arrive.

Watching it, many people must lament that in AI and robotics, the very field where the Japanese should have been strongest, Japan has not merely fallen behind but has failed even to raise a ripple. Yet when I look at the fierce race between the United States and China, the two powers now leading the field, I feel that what we need to understand is the “difference in thought” that shows itself there.

To begin with, the Japanese, and the Chinese too, feel almost no resistance toward AI and robots. In the West that resistance runs very deep, and even the question of bringing them into society divides opinion bitterly. Japan and China, in essence, have no such problem. Until around the 1990s, the Japanese saw a mind in machines and set out to make robots as a way of giving form to a mind; anime alone shows how consistent that sensibility has been.

In this the Chinese seem to me no different. But there is one thing I want to think about this week.
It is to turn the Western question “Do AI and robots have a mind?” into the Eastern question “What is the mind?” In other words, to bring the subject, “AI” or “robot,” to nothing, and to set thought in motion the Eastern way.

In the West, as everyone knows, seeing a mind in AI or robots is dismissed at once as absurd and met with fierce scorn. For East Asians, though, it is in essence a mind all the same, and in that sense there is no difference of mind between a human being, nature, a robot, or AI. When East Asia speaks of differences of mind, it means differences in the degree and manner in which the mind shows itself. The mind at its source is the same in all things, without the slightest difference.

When people try to account for this way of thinking, they are usually in such a hurry to explain it that they reach for animism. That is not it. What I always look to is a word found in the Chinese teachings that shaped the East Asian world so powerfully: tenri (天理), the heavenly principle, the order Heaven lays into every thing.

The Doctrine of the Mean begins, in its very first chapter (天命之謂性、率性之謂道、修道之謂教): “What Heaven decrees is called nature; following nature is called the Way; cultivating the Way is called teaching.” We must remember that the teachings written with this thought at their core are still alive in the depths of the East Asian spirit.

Behind the Doctrine of the Mean lies the premise that the heavenly principle is spoken of as “nature,” sei (性), what each thing receives from Heaven. And because the heavenly principle dwells in all things as their nature, the “mind” generated from it is not split off, as the West imagines, into separate owners. It is furi (不離), inseparable from everything else, and it is not something turned into a subject. As we saw with the Japanese language in this week’s Forest of Thought, it is the appearance of a predicative world.

If I am to speak of the mind in my own way, it is something generated in the relations among all things within the nature of the heavenly principle, and at its root lies what Kitaro Nishida called “the place of absolute nothingness.” In Nishida’s words, the place of absolute nothingness is the original place from which all being and all nothingness are generated. Here Nishida saw through to something more: that even the “nothingness” imagined by Buddhist monks and Taoists is not the origin, but is itself generated in relation.

The place of absolute nothingness, in other words, is the first source from which the nature of the heavenly principle is generated through relation. What those relations bring forth and nurture is simply what we have come to call the “mind.”

Split the mind off, and we end up assuming that each individual owns one. Seen from the East Asian tradition, the mind is present in all things, and it dwells, moreover, in the nature of the heavenly principle.

Think about this root of cultural spirit, and it becomes clear why East Asia treats any debate over whether to “grant a mind” to today’s AI and robots as needless and barren, and why it meets them with more affection than anyone. To fear the unknown and be anxious before it is to look at the world from a state in which everything has been split apart. In that sense too, we can see that East Asians live in a very different world. And this cultural spirit is, in effect, the fundamental reason China leads the world in AI and robotics. In this sense, I feel, the West will probably never overtake China.

The reason is not that China lives under the dictatorship of the Communist Party. In the West, the only way to build a social relationship with AI and robots is through regulation and law, and the West must also spend its time being tossed about by arguments with Christian values. China stands in a context apart from that tradition, and so it can rise all at once from the standpoint of the nature of the heavenly principle. The technology may be the same the world over, but AI and robots, these past few years, may be where the difference in fundamental thought shows most clearly.

Amid all this swaying, I think there is real value in looking at Japan, a country that belongs to the East Asian tradition yet is being dragged along by the West at the same time. But when the question of the mind of AI and robots is raised in Japan, we must not let it be reduced to animism.

Next week, I will write about AI, robots, and the world of animism.